Jump to:
Of the four quarter finals, this is the one that feels most like a genuine 50-50 on paper.
Forest Shuffle is a newer game with a strong recent following. Lords of Waterdeep has been one of the best gateway worker placement games for over a decade. Neither has the name recognition of Wingspan or Terraforming Mars. Neither has the devoted hardcore following of Root or Pandemic. What they both have is a large pool of players who genuinely enjoy them, and in a popular vote that is what matters.
This one could go either way. Let’s work out why.
Just waqnt to vote, you can
How They Got Here
Forest Shuffle has had the more spectacular tournament run. It beat Sky Team 100-0 in the Round of 64, which remains one of the more surprising whitewashes of the whole competition. It then beat Viticulture 78-22 in the Round of 32, Jaipur 83-17 in the Round of 16, and came through the bottom half of the draw without dropping below 78% in any match. It has not been seriously tested.
Lords of Waterdeep has worked harder for its results. It beat Blood on the Clocktower 67-33 in the Round of 32, knocked out SETI 90-10 in the Round of 16, and then came through a tighter-than-expected 57-43 win over Harmonies in the last round. That Harmonies result is the one worth noting: Lords of Waterdeep nearly dropped a match to a 2024 tile-laying game that most people had not heard of a year ago.
Forest Shuffle has the momentum. Lords of Waterdeep has the experience of being pushed and coming through.
What Forest Shuffle Actually Is
Forest Shuffle is a card game designed by Kosch and published by Lookout Games in 2023. You are building a forest by planting trees and then attracting the plants, insects, birds, and mammals that live under and around them. The core mechanism is simple: on your turn you either play a tree card to start a new space in your forest, or you tuck a non-tree card underneath a tree of the matching type to give it a habitat.
What makes it interesting is how the cards interact. Each card has an immediate effect when played, a set of end-game scoring conditions, and sometimes an ongoing ability. A woodpecker might score points for every dead tree in your forest. A bluebell might score for the number of different plant species nearby. A bat scores based on how many insects you have. Building a forest that satisfies multiple scoring conditions at once is the real puzzle.
The game ends when a winter card is revealed from the deck. There are eight winter cards, and when the fifth one appears the game is over and you score. This means the length is slightly variable, which can catch newer players out, but it also means the game creates natural tension around the deck as it thins.
Forest Shuffle plays two to five players and takes about 45 minutes once everyone knows the cards. The first game is slower because there are a lot of different species and people want to read everything. By the second game it moves quickly and the decisions are genuinely interesting.
The production is lovely. The artwork on the cards is clean and naturalistic, which fits the theme perfectly. If you like Wingspan’s combination of real-world natural history and engine-building card play, Forest Shuffle is worth your time, though the mechanism is different enough that calling it a Wingspan clone would be unfair to both games.
What Lords of Waterdeep Actually Is
Lords of Waterdeep is a worker placement game designed by Peter Lee and Rodney Thompson and published by Wizards of the Coast in 2012. You play as one of the masked lords of Waterdeep, the city at the heart of the Forgotten Realms D&D universe, sending agents out to locations around the city to gather adventurers, gold, and magic, then spending those resources to complete quests.
Worker placement, if you haven’t come across it, is a genre where you place tokens on a shared board to take actions, with the key constraint that each space can only be used by one player per round. The tension comes from racing to claim the actions you need before someone else takes them.
Lords of Waterdeep is one of the best introductions to the genre because the actions are intuitive. You send agents to the harbour to recruit fighters, to the tavern to hire rogues, to the tower to find wizards, to the market to get gold. It makes thematic sense in a way that more abstract worker placement games sometimes don’t manage.
The quest cards are the game’s main variable. You start with a secret lord card that tells you which quest types score bonus points for you, and the quests you complete are your primary scoring mechanism. There is also an Intrigue card system that lets you interfere with other players, which adds a light layer of direct interaction that the pure resource-gathering loop doesn’t have on its own.
Lords of Waterdeep plays two to five players and takes 60 to 90 minutes. It is the game I have recommended most often to people who want to try worker placement but find heavier games like Agricola or Caverna intimidating. It has the D&D brand behind it, which helps with a certain type of new player, and it is polished enough that almost every session runs smoothly.
Where They Are Similar
Both games are card-driven at their core. In Forest Shuffle the cards are the game. In Lords of Waterdeep the quest cards and intrigue cards provide the variable objectives and occasional disruption. Both games play in under 90 minutes. Both have a clean enough structure that they can be taught to relative newcomers without a lengthy rules session.
Both games also have a strong replayability argument. Forest Shuffle changes because the cards that come up and the order they appear shifts the puzzle every time. Lords of Waterdeep changes because the combination of lord cards, quest distribution, and building upgrades creates a different game state each session.
They also share a similar player count sweet spot. Both work at three to four players in my experience. Forest Shuffle at two is slightly thin; Lords of Waterdeep at two works but loses some of the placement tension that makes the genre sing.
Where They Are Different
The theme and setting is the most obvious difference and it matters more than people sometimes admit. Forest Shuffle is a naturalistic, quiet game. The art is calming. The subject matter is trees and animals. Lords of Waterdeep is a D&D game with rogues and wizards and quest cards called things like Recover the Magister’s Tome. One of those appeals to a very different audience than the other.
The interaction level is different too. Forest Shuffle is almost entirely non-confrontational. You are building your own forest and the only interaction is indirect: taking a card someone else wanted, revealing a winter card at an inconvenient moment. Lords of Waterdeep has the Intrigue card system, where you can send mandatory quests to opponents, steal resources, or force someone to give up adventurers. It is a light layer of conflict but it is there.
The decision texture is different. In Forest Shuffle your decisions are about which cards to play, which trees to plant, and how to balance immediate effects against end-game scoring. It is a puzzle you are solving mostly in isolation. In Lords of Waterdeep your decisions are also about what other players are doing: which quest types are they completing, which locations do they need, and when is it worth using an Intrigue card to disrupt them.
Age of the game matters too. Lords of Waterdeep has thirteen years of players behind it. The strategy is well-documented. The expansion (Scoundrels of Skullport) is widely played and broadly regarded as an improvement on the base game. Forest Shuffle is two years old and still being discovered by a lot of its eventual audience.
Which One Is Better
This is genuinely difficult and I am going to be honest about that.
Lords of Waterdeep is the more complete package as a game. The worker placement structure creates real tension, the lord card asymmetry adds strategic depth, and the Intrigue system gives experienced players a tool to disrupt and adapt. It has been a reliable game night choice for thirteen years because it is well-designed and holds up to repeated play.
Forest Shuffle is the fresher experience right now. The card interactions are satisfying in a different way, the theme is distinctive, and the naturalistic production makes it a more pleasant physical object to spend time with. As a pure card game it does things that Lords of Waterdeep cannot because it is not trying to be a worker placement game.
If I had to pick one to keep and one to give away, I would keep Lords of Waterdeep. It has done more for my games nights over a longer period of time. But I would give away Forest Shuffle reluctantly, and whoever I gave it to would enjoy it.
Who Goes Through
Forest Shuffle has been the more impressive performer in this tournament and carries the momentum. It has not dropped below 78% in any match and it has knocked out games that had stronger reputations than Lords of Waterdeep.
Lords of Waterdeep has thirteen years of players behind it and a D&D brand that means something to a large portion of the board gaming community. The 57-43 win over Harmonies suggests it has a solid vote floor, even if the ceiling is lower than Forest Shuffle’s.
I think Forest Shuffle wins this. The momentum is real and the game is currently at peak discovery, which means the people voting for it are the people who just played it and loved it.